Forum Home
Press F1
 
Thread ID: 62301 2005-10-03 23:00:00 Athlon 64 or Pentium 4? zahmad (8963) Press F1
Post ID Timestamp Content User
393087 2005-10-03 23:00:00 Which is better, AMD Athlon 64 or Intel Pentium 4? I need something that I can use in my PC, and want it to be compatible to run Windows Vista when it comes out, and reviews have showed that Athlon 64 is faster and cheaper, but Intel has a higher clock speed. Dos the clock speed matter? zahmad (8963)
393088 2005-10-03 23:07:00 amd uses a different kind of clock speed, ie a amd64 3400+ is equvilent to a P4 3.4Ghz.

what will you be using your computer for? general internet browsing, emails or games?

yes AMD is ranking higher than Intel at the moment.
Prescott (11)
393089 2005-10-03 23:16:00 I am goign to use it for general use, but sometimes playing games like Unreal tournament, Need for Speed Underground, etc. zahmad (8963)
393090 2005-10-03 23:39:00 AMD is better, and has been for 90 percent of the time since around the time the Athlon 700 hit the market. Metla (12)
393091 2005-10-03 23:55:00 I have only used Intels so far (but then I have only been computing since XP), and although I have had no issues with my current one (2.6 - warranty replacement for a 1.6 that threw in the towel) I know that later ones have had some issues. From what I have been reading, I would have to agree with Metla, for quite a while in the past and who knows how far in the future; AMD would be better value Myth (110)
393092 2005-10-03 23:58:00 AMD rules.... pctek (84)
393093 2005-10-04 00:03:00 Not that Im biased... :D :D

www.computermedic.co.nz
Metla (12)
393094 2005-10-04 04:34:00 Im with Metla and pctek also, 64-bit Athlon Chilling_Silence (9)
393095 2005-10-04 05:50:00 AMD64's performs far more operations per clock cycle than P4 , which is the quick technical way of explaining it. Can't compare clock cycles of the two as its Apples and oranges.

Simple old example
Which is faster a 386 DX40 or a 486 DX40, which both run at 40 MHZ. The correct answer is 486 DX40, its architecture is superior.


Pro's to buying AMD64 or P4
*AMD64 run cooler
*Use less Power
*Out Perform P4 in Virtually all games and "some" apps.

Cons
*Run a little slower in some multitasking and apps due to no HT


There is no good reasons to go P4 unless you have very specific apps that will benefit from hyper-threading, but for 95%+ of the general public should buy AMD 64 as they are simply higher performers when compared at the similar pricing levels.
Battleneter (60)
393096 2005-10-04 07:19:00 I'd go the the Ahtlon 64s anyday over the Pentiums... Plus they run colder than the P4s.... Azrael (4666)
1 2 3 4