Forum Home
PC World Chat
 
Thread ID: 57750 2005-05-11 14:15:00 Phone Book Designs. Jams (1051) PC World Chat
Post ID Timestamp Content User
354210 2005-05-11 14:15:00 hey all.

I just picked up the 2005 Phone book for manawatu, now, im not sure if its the same with phonebooks around the country, but...why are the designs on the front of the phonebooks always so.....crap. Im a second Year Design student, i should be embracing these.....but there just so.......crap.

anyone else realised this ?
Jams (1051)
354211 2005-05-11 16:29:00 Probally picked the winner from a contest of primary school kids.

Next time you see a little kid you can tell them you have a lot of training in design work and quite frankly you are much better at drawing than they are. :D
Rob99 (151)
354212 2005-05-11 18:41:00 art is subjective

please post some of your work here so I can say I spent 2 years dating an art student and I embraced her a lot but I still think your work is crap.
sam m (517)
354213 2005-05-11 21:48:00 Yep. Here in the Wairarapa, not long ago, we had a shocking bit of 'art' on the cover.
I had to cover it up so I did not vomit for the entire year.

Local committees choose the art for the covers.
Find out who are on the committee (just ring the local art museum - they will know), so when they choose the next one, you can avert another disaster next year. Also, write a letter to the editor of the local newspaper - maybe after speaking with the chairperson of the art committee - quote whatever excuse they feed to you.
Strommer (42)
354214 2005-05-11 21:56:00 Can you give us a photo of it? Strommer (42)
354215 2005-05-11 22:01:00 The advantages of VOIP/Skype ;) Edward (31)
354216 2005-05-11 22:18:00 art is subjective

please post some of your work here so I can say I spent 2 years dating an art student and I embraced her a lot but I still think your work is crap.

i dont do art......design and art are different things.
Jams (1051)
354217 2005-05-11 23:15:00 i dont do art......design and art are different things.. Well...that qualifies you to comment on others' choice of art. Apparently one of the medieval popes once said that he didn't know much about art but he knew what he didn't like...... or was it Monty Python? :cool: Scouse (83)
354218 2005-05-11 23:25:00 So only those with an art education are allowed to voice an opinion?

Is this right across the board?

I mean, Im no engineer, am I allowed to say I think the Taurus is a pig ugly car?

I'm no landscape gardener but I think my back yard is poorly done, I don't know much about computers ,am I allowed to say Dells are awesome machines?


Art and Art lovers would have to be one of mankinds biggest jokes.
Metla (12)
354219 2005-05-12 00:00:00 Jams - As the artist Su Hendeles lives in Palmy I suggest you look her up and tell her to her face that you think her work is crap. Take along a portfolio of your work to show her how brilliant you are and she may even tell you the difference between art and design. Dally (6292)
1 2