Forum Home
Press F1
 
Thread ID: 99112 2009-04-20 12:41:00 P4 Motherboard comparisons minster (9180) Press F1
Post ID Timestamp Content User
766566 2009-04-20 12:41:00 Hi,
After building a new system for my partner, I have inherited her Acer that has,
Intel Pentium 4 516, 2933 MHz mobo SiS 661GX
1024 MB (PC3200 DDR SDRAM
160 GB ram
RADEON 9200 PRO (128mb)
Socket 775

Yeah I know it's an Acer but apart from the sign on the box you wouldn't know as I have removed all the acer bloat a long time back.
My idea is that as the Acer is about 2 years newer and in a lot nicer condition than my machine (cosmetically) that I would swap a lot of the better hardware from my pc to the acer (for my own use)
I have checked out the specs of both using Everest and the majority is identical but there are a couple of points I am unsure of.
Acer has Socket 775
2933 MHz
versus
My pc is Socket 478
3000 MH

I will be changing,
PSU 300 to 450W
1gb Ram to 2 GB
Radeon 9250 AGP to a nVIDIA GeForce 7600 GS AGP
plus adding my lg dvd writer

Both GPUs are AGP and the ram is all DDR PC3200

I would like to know if I am making an improvement or whether it's a waste of time doing this just basically to get a tidier and newer machine?
minster (9180)
766567 2009-04-20 13:00:00 Keep the socket 775 processor, it will be *slightly* faster than the socket 478 due to the faster bus I think.

You should see a nice performance boost from upgrading the RAM(assuming you're running XP and not vista:p)

And performance in games should be much nicer too, a much faster GFX card upgrade.

Blam
Blam (54)
766568 2009-04-20 13:05:00 The 775 is in the acer now and that's what I'll be using, as well as the 2gig ram and 7600 card.
It's just I'm unsure of the 2.93 mhz that the acer has or the 3.00 mhz that my pc has. Will I be going back by using the acer?
All XP:)
minster (9180)
766569 2009-04-20 13:10:00 The only thing with the 775 pin is the ram, it would probably go faster with DDR 2 ram (which it probably doesnt support)

You would have to change the mobo
Speedy Gonzales (78)
766570 2009-04-20 13:14:00 I will be staying with the 2 gb ddr pc3200 as it's free:)

(Poor old pensioner here:))
minster (9180)
766571 2009-04-20 13:21:00 The 775 is in the acer now and that's what I'll be using, as well as the 2gig ram and 7600 card.
It's just I'm unsure of the 2.93 mhz that the acer has or the 3.00 mhz that my pc has. Will I be going back by using the acer?
All XP:)

Both would be similar except the older 478 socket one would be better for OC'ing and the 775 would be faster at stock speeds since it has a faster bus
Blam (54)
766572 2009-04-20 13:25:00 Thanks for the heads up:)
Should be finished and all up running again after a full format tomorrow afternoon:)
minster (9180)
1