Forum Home
PC World Chat
 
Thread ID: 86310 2008-01-12 03:13:00 Blu Ray Wins HD Format War Morpheus1 (186) PC World Chat
Post ID Timestamp Content User
629594 2008-01-12 03:13:00 Read all about it: bits.blogs.nytimes.com

While nothing is definite at this stage it does look like the last two major studios backing HD DVD — NBC Universal and Paramount — will switch to Blu-ray.

Another article:

www.variety.com
Morpheus1 (186)
629595 2008-01-12 03:24:00 I hope Blu Ray doesn't win

I support toshiba .
Ninjabear (2948)
629596 2008-01-12 03:30:00 The "war" so far has hardly started, It takes place on the retail floor, All the backyard deals mean nothing.

So far regular DVD is winning by miles. The consumer is largly content, Everyone else is just blowing millions and millions of dollars on a unwanted format.

If it was wanted, Sales would have dictated who was to win.
Metla (12)
629597 2008-01-12 03:40:00 Sony have mentioned special Blu Ray movie releases for their portable PSP, which then can be copied in to the PSP 3 memory stick. Also Ritek have announced a disk to burn Bly Ray on one side and HD-DVD on the other... kahawai chaser (3545)
629598 2008-01-12 03:49:00 I'm betting on bluray since I just got a PS3. Although Hi Def wasn't the reason I got it, gaming wasn't either. originally was looking at an appleTv, but while it did what it well, it didn't do much. Very pleased so far using the PS3 as a media center. plod (107)
629599 2008-01-12 04:55:00 The "war" so far has hardly started, It takes place on the retail floor, All the backyard deals mean nothing.

So far regular DVD is winning by miles. The consumer is largly content, Everyone else is just blowing millions and millions of dollars on a unwanted format.

If it was wanted, Sales would have dictated who was to win.Agreed. Most on the shop floor are quite content to just buy ordinary DVD. Its really only the fanboys who are at war
Myth (110)
629600 2008-01-12 07:25:00 According to my feeds, New Line Cinema and HBO home video has also just switched exclusively to Blu-ray format. Just need to convince the public I guess to switch from DVD to the higher def Blu-ray... kahawai chaser (3545)
629601 2008-01-12 08:50:00 From what I have read, Using a dvd player that upscales a normal DVD picture to HD resolutions (these are the players with HDMI output) gives a picture so good that people couldn't tell the difference.

Although the size and quality of the TV would have an impact, and of course how anal the viewer is.

MY EYES ,MY EYES, I SAW A JAGGIE, THIS IS HORRIBLE, MY POOR EYES, THEY ARE BLEEDING, KILL THIS LOW RESOLUTION OUTPUT BEFORE IT KILLS SOMEONE, I HAVE ALREADY BEEN BLINDED.
Metla (12)
629602 2008-01-12 09:00:00 From what I have read, Using a dvd player that upscales a normal DVD picture to HD resolutions (these are the players with HDMI output) gives a picture so good that people couldn't tell the difference.

Although the size and quality of the TV would have an impact, and of course how anal the viewer is.

MY EYES ,MY EYES, I SAW A JAGGIE, THIS IS HORRIBLE, MY POOR EYES, THEY ARE BLEEDING, KILL THIS LOW RESOLUTION OUTPUT BEFORE IT KILLS SOMEONE, I HAVE ALREADY BEEN BLINDED.

Well after watching casino royal on blu-ray and watching diehard 4 on normal dvd using the same player and the same tv. I have to say they both look great. Unless I can see the same movie being played side by side on the two formats I'm going to with hold judgement
plod (107)
629603 2008-01-12 09:13:00 With your PS3?

Made by the company pushing blue-ray?

Can I put 2 and 2 together for you?

If it upscales DVD at all (which I doubt), There is no way in hell they will configure there device to give a picture anywhere close to Blue-Ray.

What you would have to do is use a Standalone DVD player with a good upscaler outputting through HDMI.

There is no suggestion that HD isn't higher quality then DVD, Just that a Good upscaler can produce a comparable image.

However, I haven't seen it for myself, So Im not willing to lay any big bets.

I will however buy a new cheap DVD player that outputs through HDMI rather then invest in a HD or Blue-Ray player.

But that could change.
Metla (12)
1 2 3 4