Forum Home
Press F1
 
Thread ID: 118794 2011-06-21 07:06:00 Brother HL 2140 printer - New drum a good idea ? Digby (677) Press F1
Post ID Timestamp Content User
1210947 2011-06-21 07:06:00 Hi Guys
I have one of these printers and am very pleased with it.

It says I need a new drum, this is about $140 for a genuine Brother one or $80 for a compatable one.

Should I buy one of these or may be just buy a new printer.
My point is that all the rollers and belts etc are wearing out and I may get more paper jams with my current printer, versus the plain sailing that I should get with a new one ! ?

(This is my second Brother pinter of the same design)
Digby (677)
1210948 2011-06-21 08:26:00 With Brother printers I have found it's cheap to replace the whole printer though the 2140 must be nearly end of life so you may find some bargains.... paulw (1826)
1210949 2011-06-21 08:34:00 dicksmith.co.nz

Cheaper than a new drum. And it can be had cheaper elsewhere.
ryanjames.powell (13554)
1210950 2011-06-21 11:05:00 Yes I was thinking it would be best to buy a whole new printer.

Isn't that crazy how it works these days.

Not much dearer to get a whole new machine than just a drum !

Yes that new HL 2130 looks nice.

(but it takes different toner carts and drums)
Digby (677)
1210951 2011-06-21 11:09:00 Buy a new printer - it will be cheaper :) Zippity (58)
1210952 2011-06-22 04:25:00 If it hasn't stopped and is still printing OK, run it till its stuffed.
You might be luckly and there is still abit more life in it.
Jeff (1070)
1210953 2011-07-01 03:38:00 Instead of replacing the printer, go on ebay and look for a Brother HL 2140 drum - NOT the drum cartridge - just the drum. This is about $15 USD. I'm not sure what that translates to in your currency. The drum is a circular tube and fits inside of the drum cartridge. It is very simple to replace and the ones on ebay come with instructions. That is it. It is FAR cheaper to replace the parts with items off of eBay than it is to get genuine Brother parts. One brother toner cartridge was more than I paid for my printer! hatetoregister (16436)
1210954 2011-07-01 23:01:00 Instead of replacing the printer, go on ebay and look for a Brother HL 2140 drum - NOT the drum cartridge - just the drum. This is about $15 USD. I'm not sure what that translates to in your currency. The drum is a circular tube and fits inside of the drum cartridge. It is very simple to replace and the ones on ebay come with instructions. That is it. It is FAR cheaper to replace the parts with items off of eBay than it is to get genuine Brother parts. One brother toner cartridge was more than I paid for my printer!

But it will cost US$30+ to send it here..
paulw (1826)
1210955 2011-07-02 00:33:00 Had exactly the same choice as you can cancel the drum light and run it till the toner is empty like empty not printing mt instead of toner light mt.
Then you have a choice of spending over $250 for a new drum and toner or buying the latest version Brother HL-2130 at $90 and throwing the old printer down the bank on a lonely country road.
prefect (6291)
1210956 2011-07-02 01:27:00 Thanks for all the suggestions guys.

I am going to phone my local Cartridge World for their prices for a new drum cartridge.

But my main question is that if you replace the drum cartridge, then other parts of the printer may start playing up, eg the rollers will be getting worn and dry and I may get more paper jams etc.

This happened to me on my first Brother.

Whereas with a new printer its all new again.

It does seem crazy how the pricing structure works.
Digby (677)
1