Forum Home
Press F1
 
Thread ID: 125889 2012-07-25 07:55:00 A poll har (16834) Press F1
Post ID Timestamp Content User
1290723 2012-07-25 07:55:00 Should schools have a compulsory rule to bring laptops etc. har (16834)
1290724 2012-07-25 08:00:00 Can i ask what the point in this is? stratex5 (16685)
1290725 2012-07-25 08:39:00 Yes, especially the etc. inphinity (7274)
1290726 2012-07-25 08:47:00 Can i ask what the point in this is?
and what was the point of your question?
Primary school a no but secondary school yes.
mikebartnz (21)
1290727 2012-07-25 08:52:00 Wants support to persuade his Mum to buy him one for school.
(And he would subsequently, quite coincidentally, discover to his absolute astonishment that it can be used to play games.)
coldot (6847)
1290728 2012-07-25 09:00:00 Wants support to persuade his Mum to buy him one for school.
(And he would subsequently, quite coincidentally, discover to his absolute astonishment that it can be used to play games.)

Lol too true:D
stratex5 (16685)
1290729 2012-07-25 09:21:00 From Level one (5th form/ Year 11) Upwareds, yes. Before that there is no reason for a kid to require a laptop for school. Even at NCEA level there shouldn't be a Requirement at this stage, at least no until schools have a fully integrated and viable way of doing things. By fully I mean that every single school task can be accomplished on a range of devices (windows/apple and ubuntu (I say ubuntu because it's the most popular and easy to use *nix distro for people who can't afford windows, any will do))

Integration should include at least these to name a few:

A secure and robust network that can cope with the volume of traffic from students as well as protect against bypass/threas such as VPN and torrents
Power points to give the people power
Online work distribution/marking (moodle is good for this)
Student Management of some sort to ensure all are on task
Networked printers and appropriate print management.
Robust network protection against plenty of novice users bringing their infected machines onto the network
More network protection against malicious students (schoolzone is appalling, basic auth for proxy and SSL is unencrypted over the LAN. As proof of concept I was able to capture my own back account details and login from a remote machine. With plenty of boarders accessing banking online there is a huge potential for malicious phishing)

No point in requiring laptops unless the whole school experience is fully integrated. If you can't integrate properly then computers should be an accessory rather than a requirement otherwise they become a hindrance to productivity as time is spent fixing issues and minimising downtime rather than working on education.


My :2cents:
The Error Guy (14052)
1290730 2012-07-25 09:32:00 Personally the question seems too ambiguous to answer... pcuser42 (130)
1290731 2012-07-25 09:40:00 :spam:spam Trev (427)
1290732 2012-07-25 10:33:00 and what was the point of your question?

I thought i made my point quite clear, but apparently not, or mabye some people just dont have the intuletual capability to understand. I guess if you ask a silly question like that you'll get a silliy (or somewhat truthful) reply;)
stratex5 (16685)
1 2 3 4