Forum Home
Press F1
 
Thread ID: 26526 2002-10-29 09:16:00 need advice for purchasing a scanner chinadoll (682) Press F1
Post ID Timestamp Content User
94255 2002-10-29 09:16:00 I am thinking to buy a scanner with adapter for slides or negative, which I want to scan and print out to postcard size or larger than that.
So, I wonder HP5370c or canon D1250u2f will be good enough to handle it or I should go for Hp5470c or Canon D2400uf.

Any suggestions will be appreciated.

Thank you (_)(_)
chinadoll (682)
94256 2002-10-29 09:23:00 > I am thinking to buy a scanner with adapter for
> slides or negative, which I want to scan and print
> out to postcard size or larger than that.
> So, I wonder HP5370c or canon D1250u2f will be good
> enough to handle it or I should go for Hp5470c or
> Canon D2400uf.

i would go for the Canon D2400uf. i had all sorts of problems with HP printers and scanners and just "gave up" on HP products. the Canon D1250uf should be just sweet, but buy the D2400uf if u want slightly better dpi and improved clarity.

cheers,
v.K
vk_dre (195)
94257 2002-10-29 09:30:00 I personally haven’t had any problem with hp scanners but I would probably go with the cannon as hp scanners are very expensive.

One thing to look out for is whether they use LED to illuminate the scanned object or whether they use a fluro lamp, fluro lamps provide better quality but wear out quicker (especially if they’re left on 24/7), however led are pretty much indestructible but do provide quite so good quality.


Hope this helps.


Cheers

Liam
nz_liam (845)
94258 2002-10-29 09:48:00 I'm with VK_dre on this one...

DHP

SiK
SoniKalien (792)
94259 2002-10-29 10:04:00 if u need a 35mm negative scanner. canon u need to use fluoro... LED cannot be used for 35mm's.

depend how pro u are?? a 35mm scanner like by Canon or Nikon Coolscan will always produce the best results but comes at a price. Every Nikon has been rated as excellent by various forums.
rayonline (2134)
94260 2002-10-29 11:21:00 Thenks guys for the advice.

I think I will go for Canon. It just for home use scan few slides and negative from time to time. But I like to have good dpi.

I wonder Canon D1250U2F will be good enough or not?

If any one out there own one of that?

Please,more advice will be welcomed.

Thank you (_)(_)
chinadoll (682)
94261 2002-10-30 05:41:00 > I wonder Canon D1250U2F will be good enough or not?

yep, it should be, the D1250u2f should handle well and reliable, the other model is for slightly higher specs. have a look here (www.canon.com.au) for specs on the D1250u2f model and have a look here (www.canon.com.au) for specs on the D2400UF.

cheers,
v.K
vk_dre (195)
1