Forum Home
Press F1
 
Thread ID: 28494 2002-12-21 06:50:00 Router Comparsion ~~~~~ s y ~~~~~ (2054) Press F1
Post ID Timestamp Content User
107971 2002-12-23 11:11:00 I Don't know if this is on the same topic but can someone tell me the difference between a Router and a Proxy server. I have a pc running 95 as a proxy server for the net, another pc running NT4 as the main server and various other pc's running 98 & 2k as workstations. They are all connected via a 3 Com super stacker hub. I am attempting to connect another pc running Redhat 7.3 and failing miserably (but that is another matter). We have just had jetstream become available in our area would I need a router to use Jetstream? Jacc (2576)
107972 2002-12-23 19:20:00 In essence, a router connects two networks and only passes packets between networks that are intended for each other (as opposed to joining two networks with a hub - that will expose all traffic to both networks).
A proxy server is an intermediate between nodes making a request and the server that fulfills the requests. There are many reasons you might use a proxy (local caching to improve response etc). If you are using a proxy to access the web, you are most likely using it for NAT (Network Address Translation), that allows multiple local PC's to share a single IP address on the internet side.

A DSL router offers the same facility (as a NAT router), so in effect could replace your proxy PC (if it was only required for NAT), or you could use a DSL modem in the proxy PC.
wuppo (41)
107973 2002-12-25 02:35:00 Thank You, that helps me get a better understanding. Yes we are using the proxy so that more than one computer can access the net at once. I keep telling the kids that when they can keep their rooms clean they can get internet access on their computers but it doesn't seem to work.
Jacc
Jacc (2576)
107974 2002-12-27 21:27:00 So who can suggest a good router that is not too expensive that allows pinholing of port ranges instead of just single ports as my Dynalink currently does.

I may just buy a USB external DSL modem and be done with and keep the router active except for when I want to do specific things.
Big John (551)
107975 2002-12-27 21:59:00 We have the Dlink 505 at work. Its similar to the 500 but allows vpn. Haven't used vpn yet, but as one of the owners travels a lot I thought we should go that way for future options. We have no problem with it. It has 4 ports, but is plugged into an 8 port router. wotz (335)
107976 2002-12-28 01:14:00 The Vigor 2600 would seem to have it all according to the write-up:
www.draytek.co.uk
Terry Porritt (14)
107977 2002-12-28 01:23:00 I suppose the main problem would be lack of a Telepermit, even though the NZ PTC specs are or were based on BT standards.
http://www.telepermit.co.nz/
Terry Porritt (14)
107978 2002-12-28 01:28:00 Vigor looks good alright. Know anywhere in NZ where it can be purchased from? Big John (551)
107979 2002-12-28 02:35:00 I couldnt find any reference to the Vigor in NZ, but I'll email DrayTek and ask if they have agents here or in Aussie. However I think they supply only to the UK and EU. The Vigor would most probably be compatible with Telecom ADSL, but if there is no local supplier, then there wont be a Telepermit. Terry Porritt (14)
107980 2002-12-28 03:53:00 The Asus AAM6000EV allows ranges for TCP / UDP port translations (can map an 'external range' to a different 'internal' range, if so required). This unit is available at a bit over $200 + GST. wuppo (41)
1 2 3 4