Forum Home
Press F1
 
Thread ID: 30165 2003-02-12 04:20:00 adsl modem floyds (3095) Press F1
Post ID Timestamp Content User
120506 2003-02-12 04:20:00 whats better - ethernet or usb?

thanx
floyds (3095)
120507 2003-02-12 04:24:00 Ethernet as the modem/router usually as NAT built into it which is a good firewall.
Also easier if you want more than one PC to share the internet as there is no PC that must be on all the time. (as there would be with a USB modem)
CYaBro (73)
120508 2003-02-12 05:06:00 ive been told that a usb sucks alot of power? there will only be 1 computer on the modem as well.

cheers
floyds (3095)
120509 2003-02-12 19:07:00 USB uses power, it wouldn't take 'that' much power, I believe it gives out a max of 5v??? so no change in your powerbill.

I would recommend a router, they are heaps safer from crackers etc, and you can get a decent one for around $250, I was looking at the Dynalink 210, which is $250 from qmb... has NAT so you'd be pretty safe

- David
DangerousDave (697)
120510 2003-02-12 19:42:00 From what I have seen, USB Modems are pretty limited in options - as are internal ones. As for power usage you are only talking in milliamps and probably a Max of 750mA (@5V = 3.75W). ADSL Routers (Ethernet) are a lot more handy and yes - secure. With NAT, port forwarding and even real firewalling if you want (although the rules are tricky & time consuming) - the Dynalinks are nice to deal with.. Beats the overbearing cost of a Nokia M1122! :P kiwistag (2875)
120511 2003-02-12 23:11:00 > I would recommend a router, they are heaps safer from
> crackers etc, and you can get a decent one for around
> $250, I was looking at the Dynalink 210, which is

I have a 210 but it suffers from CRC errors and locks up when it gets too many which requires a shutdown of the unit and repower.

Currently a Vigor 2600 is winging its way from Holland for me to try out. Cost me $540 but has a 4 port auto sensing switch built in which detects the type of cable you plug into it and changes to suit it. Also has a full firewall/NAT built in as well.
Big John (551)
120512 2003-02-13 00:26:00 USB are akin to WinModems, they tend to rely on your PC for some of their processing. External ethernet are the way to go.

My personal preference is the Asus AAM6000.
antmannz (28)
120513 2003-02-13 01:13:00 Ethernet is "mature" technology. It usually works.

People do seem to have problems using printers, scanners, and modems on USB ports. :-( Maybe USB will be a Good Thing. One day, when they get it right. :D
Graham L (2)
1