Forum Home
Press F1
 
Thread ID: 31589 2003-03-26 09:37:00 Buying Suggestions heni72847 (1166) Press F1
Post ID Timestamp Content User
131052 2003-03-27 08:52:00 it can be a number of factors, including quality of components used (i dont know if any of you are aware of abit's past habit of using cheap capacitors which had a tendency to leak or even explode), featureset, aftersales support, and asus boards do have a reputation for being well balanced between stability and performance.

as with everything you get what you pay for, and with asus you are usually buying into stability, performance and long term reliability on a scale that many other mobo manufacturers fail to touch. I've owned quite a few mobo brands over the years and asus products have consistently been the ones that stick around.. all my server gear is asus based now

ECS should be good, as they are basically the low-cost arm of Asus.

another brand i can recommend is MSI - excellent bang for the buck and usually featurepacked. my last mobo was an MSI and I didnt have any problem with it.
whetu (237)
131053 2003-03-27 09:06:00 tweak'e has it right...

I'd avoid chaintech - I run a PC sales business, and I tested a couple of different chaintech boards (the much-hyped Apogee among them), which ran OK in the tests - not fantastic boards, but they are good value.

However, when I started selling them, I had four boards returned in a little over a month.

Asus would probably be your best bet for a quality motherboard. There are of course many other motherboard manufacturers who can supply you an excellent product - Soltek are my recommendation, but if money is no object, then you've no reason not to buy Asus. By my record, Asus and Soltek are equally reliable and powerful, but Asus is better known, and has been making the best boards for longer.

Gigabyte also have some fantastic boards if you're looking for a P4 system. Serial ATA RAID, AGP 8X, Dual Channel DDR, and support for HT are common among their top boards, and Gigabyte can definately be relied upon.

My advice - Soltek for Athlon, Gigabyte for P4, and if you're not worried about cost, then Asus for both.

:)

Erin
Erin Salmon (626)
131054 2003-03-27 09:37:00 Hi heni

All aboard for my 1c worth. I basically agree with those above re Asus. I have 1 Asus based machine and 1 Soltek based machine both socket A. And have had no problems with either. The Asus board is at the budget end of their scale with onboard grfx (nforce), lan and sound, agp and 3 pci slots. Easy as to set up and hasn't missed a beat in the relatively short time its been running. The Soltek was a mid range buy (only sound onboard) but similarly hasn't missed a beat unlike some of the dodgy product I've owned. Just makes life so much easier with a good solid base to start from.

Cheers

Murray P
Murray P (44)
131055 2003-03-27 10:01:00 thanx
gota keep these tips in my head when i'm buying my new computer
bit late for my friend though
he'd already bought it

lets just hope it won't cause too much problem...
heni72847 (1166)
131056 2003-03-27 10:59:00 While you chaps are at it,could you give opinion of my unit?
thanks lads.
SiSoftware Sandra

Computer System
Manufacturer : VIA Technologies, Inc.
Model : VT8366-8233
Unique ID : FFFFFFFF-FFFFFFFF-FFFFFFFF-FFFFFFFF

System Mainboard
Manufacturer : DFI
MP Support : No
Model : AD70-SC
BIOS ID : 02/08/2002-VT8366-8233-6A6LVD4EC-00
System Chipset : VIA KT266/A,KT333 Chipset

System Memory Controller
Location : Mainboard
Error Correction Capability : None
Number of Memory Slots : 3
Maximum Installable Memory : 768MB
Bank0/1 - A0 : DIMM 256MB
Bank2/3 - A1 : DIMM 256MB
Bank4/5 - A2 : Empty

System Chipset
Model : VIA Technologies Inc VT8366/A,VT8367 Apollo KT266/A,KT333 CPU to PCI Bridge
Bus(es) : ISA AGP PCI USB SMBus/i2c
Front Side Bus Speed : 2x 133MHz (266MHz data rate)
Max FSB Speed / Max Memory Speed : 2x 133MHz / 2x 133MHz
In Order Queue Depth : 4 req(s)

Chipset Hub Interface
Type : V-Link
Width : 8-bit
Full Duplex : Yes
Multiplier : 1x
Speed : 4x 66MHz (264MHz data rate)
Down / Up In Order Queue Depth : 9 / 9 req(s)

Logical/Chipset Memory Banks
Bank 0 Setting : 128MB DDR-SDRAM 8-1-1-1R 4-1-1-1W 2.5-3-3CL 2CMD
Bank 1 Setting : 128MB DDR-SDRAM 8-1-1-1R 4-1-1-1W 2.5-3-3CL 2CMD
Bank 2 Setting : 128MB DDR-SDRAM 8-1-1-1R 4-1-1-1W 2.5-3-3CL 2CMD
Bank 3 Setting : 128MB DDR-SDRAM 8-1-1-1R 4-1-1-1W 2.5-3-3CL 2CMD
Bank Interleave : 4-way
Speed : 2x 133MHz (266MHz data rate)
Multiplier : 1/1x
Power Down Mode : No
Fixed Hole Present : No

Memory Module(s)
Memory Module 1 : 256MB 16x(16Mx8) DDR-SDRAM PC2100U-2533-750 (CL2.5 upto 133MHz) (CL2 upto 100MHz)
Memory Module 2 : 256MB 16x(16Mx8) DDR-SDRAM PC2100U-2533-750 (CL2.5 upto 133MHz) (CL2 upto 100MHz)

Environment Monitor 1
Model : Winbond W83697HF ISA
Version : 6.00
Mainboard Specific Support : No

Temperature Sensor(s)
Board Temperature : 31.0°C / 87.8°F
CPU Temperature : 50.0°C / 122.0°F

Cooling Device(s)
Auto Fan Speed Control : No
CPU Fan Speed : 4963rpm

Voltage Sensor(s)
CPU Core Voltage : 1.76V
+3.3V Voltage : 3.28V
+5V Voltage : 4.92V
+12V Voltage : 12.89V
-12V Voltage : -12.53V
-5V Voltage : -5.40V
Standby Voltage : 4.95V
Battery Voltage : 3.30V

AGP Bus
Version : 2.00
Speed : 66MHz
Current Data Transfer Rate : 4x 66MHz (264MHz data rate)
Side Band Enabled : No
Side Band Support : Yes
Fast-Writes Enabled : No
Aperture Size : 128MB

PCI Bus(es)
Version : 2.10
No Bridges : 1
PCI Bus 0 : PCI (33MHz)
Multiplier : 1/4x

LPC Hub Controller 1
Model : VIA Technologies Inc VT8233A PCI to ISA Bridge
ACPI PM Enabled : Yes
Random Number Generator Enabled : No
Multiplier : 1/4x
Speed : 8MHz
DMA Multiplier : 1/2x
DMA Speed : 4MHz

USB Controller 1
Model : VIA Technologies Inc VT82xxxxx UHCI USB 1.1 Controller (All VIA Chipsets)
Version : 1.10
UHCI Interface : Yes
Channels : 2
Speed : 48MHz
Legacy Emulation Enabled : No

USB Controller 2
Model : VIA Technologies Inc VT8233A USB Controller
Version : 1.10
UHCI Interface : Yes
Channels : 2
Speed : 48MHz
Legacy Emulation Enabled : No

USB Controller 3
Model : VIA Technologies Inc VT8233A USB Controller
Version : 1.10
UHCI Interface : Yes
Channels : 2
Speed : 48MHz
Legacy Emulation Enabled : No

System SMBus Controller 1
Model : VIA VT823x SMBus
Speed : 16kHz

Expansion Slot(s)
PCI0 (1h) : PCI 32-bit 5V PME FullLength Available (VIA Technologies Inc VT8366/A,VT8367 Apollo KT266/A,KT333 PCI to AGP Bridge)
PCI1 (2h) : PCI 32-bit 5V PME FullLength InUse
PCI2 (3h) : PCI 32-bit 5V PME FullLength InUse
PCI3 (4h) : PCI 32-bit 5V PME FullLength Available
AGP (8h) : AGP 32-bit 5V FullLength Available (CardExpert Technology GeForce2 MX/MX 400 [NV11])

Port Connector(s)
PRIMARY IDE : None - ATA / None
SECONDARY IDE : None - ATA / None
FDD : 8251 FIFO Compatible - Floppy / None
COM1 : Serial Port 16450 Compatible - 9 Pin Dual Inline / DB-9 pin male
COM2 : Serial Port 16450 Compatible - 9 Pin Dual Inline / DB-9 pin male
LPT1 : Parallel Port ECP/EPP - DB25 pin female / DB25 pin female
Keyboard : Keyboard Port - PS/2 / PS/2
PS/2 Mouse : Mouse Port - PS/2 / PS/2
USB : USB - None / None

Performance Tips
Notice 224 : SMBIOS/DMI information may be inaccurate.
Tip 2511 : Some memory slots are free so the memory can be easily upgraded.
Warning 2545 : Large memory modules should be Registered/Buffered.
Tip 2 : Double-click tip or press Enter while a tip is selected for more information about the tip.
Thomas (1820)
131057 2003-03-27 11:00:00 >i dont know if any of you are aware of abit's past habit of using cheap capacitors which had a tendency to leak or even explode

i hope your not refering to the recent leaky capacitor problem which has plagued a few manafactures of different products.

>ECS should be good, as they are basically the low-cost arm of Asus

i thought someone here mentioned that asrock is the budget arm of asus. ECS also make the budget range of abit. not to sure on other manafactures as deals come and go. its hard to say what factory the boards are made in and by who.

ASUS are well known for there speed and amount of tweaks and updates. they are definitely not known for being stable. if you want rock solid stability then INTEL are the best. asus are known for there tweaking and over tweaking (causeing compatibility problems) their systems, however if you want the fastest............B-)
:^O
tweak'e (174)
131058 2003-03-27 11:09:00 DFI are known for their good middle of the road motherboards. the later ones have been comeing out with more overclocking features. tweak'e (174)
131059 2003-03-27 11:12:00 > > i dont know if any of you are aware of abit's past
> habit of using cheap capacitors which had a tendency
> to leak or even explode
>
> i hope your not refering to the recent leaky
> capacitor problem which has plagued a few
> manafactures of different products.

why would you hope that? its what i mean, abit got most of the attention over it though as they traditionally have a good name
whetu (237)
131060 2003-03-27 11:21:00 > > > i dont know if any of you are aware of abit's
> past
> > habit of using cheap capacitors which had a
> tendency
> > to leak or even explode
> >
> > i hope your not refering to the recent leaky
> > capacitor problem which has plagued a few
> > manafactures of different products.
>
> why would you hope that? its what i mean, abit got
> most of the attention over it though as they
> traditionally have a good name

so what if they got the most flak over it. it could have been asus or any other good manafacture that got caught out with faulty parts. it was basicly out of their control. how they fix the problem is what seperates the good manafactures from the bad.

if i remeber correctly asus made a mobo which (with origanel bios) used to KILL certain WD hardrives. mmmmmmm......pc's are so much fun ;-)
tweak'e (174)
131061 2003-03-27 11:27:00 FYI

1 if you already have the motherborad ( because you ran si-soft ) then why ask us/the fourm? because you are running it and you will know if its good or bad - for you personally - how can we judge?

A7N8x the motherboard that is STILL voted top board ( although I'd like to see pcworld.co.nz give its view on motherboard? ) by many websites.

:-)
minos#2 (318)
1 2 3